This is something that I wanted to talk about for a while, ever since I noticed a dilemma in my own life.
In High School, I took the Myers-Briggs personality test, discovering that I am an “ENTJ”.
My teacher, Mr. Smith, laughed as he told me that ENTJs are “intellectual bullies”.
I later learned that ENTJ personality types are commonly known as natural leaders, but I agree more with the title Mr. Smith handed to me. It’s not that I’m proud of being an intellectual bully, but I certainly was one in High School.
I’m sure you’ve met people like me. We argue with you simply for the sake of the argument. We get a sense of superiority out of getting you to utter the words “I don’t know”. We try to bait an emotional outburst out of your, then look smugly on as your walls slowly crumble beneath our rhetoric and facile observations.
We call ourselves Devil’s Advocates.
In High School, I thought being a Devil’s Advocate was harmless; it was just meaningless fun. However, in college, some very patient, very wise people took the time to show me that my “meaningless fun” was hurting people. I discovered that ideas have power and that thoughts are formative. I was forced to admit that the underhanded techniques I used to win debates spoke volumes about my character.
It said I was underhanded. It said that I thought thoughts were trivial. It said that my ego was the most important thing to me.
I was forced to ask, “Why does the Devil need an Advocate?”
I shown that both thoughts and people are important, and I’ve wrestled with this since then. What I think matters, and how I treat people matters too.
Yet I am a thoughtful person who still enjoys to debate and argue, but I have no desire to trample over people as I do it. So, as I mentioned above, I’ve run into a dilemma. I am a fighter who does not like to hurt people. I throw punches but do not like to bruise others. I like to win but hate when other people lose.
Sometimes two thoughtful people have important disagreements and these disagreements can hurt. After a debate, often times both people end up hurt.
You see, this has been on my mind is because of what has been happening on Facebook lately. I don’t know what it is, but I cannot look at my newsfeed without noticing people arguing. Arguments over marriage, religion, abortion, gun rights, the president, and types of phones. People are arguing. And people are getting hurt. Right there on my newsfeed.
What bothers me is my temptation to get involved in this. In High School I would have gotten involved just for the sake of arguing. In College I would not have gotten involved because I was too scared of hurting someone or getting hurt. But I see that these are important issues to be thoughtful about; I should have a stance even if I do not share it in public.
As a former intellectual bully, I’ve learned that thoughts are important and reflect who you are. I need to be thoughtful about all things, big and little, because these thoughts reflect who I am, from my favorite color to my metaphysical understanding of the universe. My actions speak volumes about what I think, and what I think will often determine how I act. Sure, there are some disconnects, but it’s true most of the time.
I am no longer a Devil’s Advocate, but I hope to be a servant of the Truth. Sometimes this means taking a hard stance and insisting on what I think is right. Sometimes this means sharing my view, even when I don’t want to, because someone asked for it. Sometimes this means shutting up because I know that I’ll be doing a bad job standing up for what is right. At ALL times this means being thoughtful and loving other people.
I’ve learned that there is a time to fight. Like any passionate activity, it is tempting to , as Nike would put it, just do it. But I’ve learned the importance of reserve, lest I hurt people tactlessly. It’s the difference between love and lust. Recovery and slothfulness. Courage and wrath.
I have an image in my head of the kind of person I want to be. I imagine a boxer who fights like beast but behaves like a gentleman, who can knock you on your ass but then helps you up. Who treats you to dinner after your fight, win or lose, and compliments your technique. Who, at the end of the day, makes you reflect on how much farther you have to go while making you happy with the progress you’ve already made.
Until I am that person, I think I’ll pick my battles carefully and train. I’ll train with those strong and patient people who are willing to endure my screw ups and shortcomings. I'll train to find a way to, as 42 put it, "[get] the guts not to fight back."